When She Met Her Newborn Sister and Cried, ‘That’s Not My Sister,’ Her Father Began to Question Everything

“Must be one of those surprises,” Claire said with a laugh. “Well, she’s a beauty. People will notice her wherever she goes with that fiery hair.” She leaned closer, studying the baby with a curious smile. “But it’s unusual, isn’t it?”

The comment landed awkwardly, and James felt his pulse quicken. “She’s unique,” he said, his voice clipped. He glanced at Susy, whose expression remained calm, though he could see the tension in her shoulders as she gently rocked the baby.